Haystack Mountain Buttercup Monterey Jack Wheel and Cuts | Revittle
Chevron down Icon

All Haystack Mountain Creamery Products

Haystack Mountain Creamery's first mixed-milk cheese, Buttercup is a blend of pasteurized local cow and goat milk. After the cheese is formed, the wheels are dipped in wax and aged for 30 to 60 days. Buttercup's name and signature pale yellow color is the result of the high beta-carotene content in the grass foraged by the cows. Haystack Mountain thinks of this mild, easygoing, semi-soft cheese as their "Swiss Army knife" in the kitchen: use it as a melter, slicer, grater, or snacker. Kids go crazy for it, but they know more than a few grown-ups do, too.

Serving Suggestions: Toasted ham-and-cheese sandwiches, macaroni and cheese, egg dishes, casseroles, quesadillas, or souffles.

Pairing Suggestions: A Dortmunder or Pilsner and Buttercup make a mean mac and cheese combo. If you're under 21, pair with a Sparking Apple or Clementine Izze for a school lunch your classmates will envy.

Ingredients: Cultured, pasteurized goat milk, cultured, pasteurized cow milk, salt, microbial rennet


CountyBoulder County
ProducerHaystack Mountain Cheese
ProductButtercup Monterey Jack
TypeMonterey Jack Style Cheese
AgingAged for More than 60 Days
Production MethodsHandcrafted
Production MethodsNo Additives
Production MethodsNo Preservatives
Production MethodsPasteurized Milk
Production MethodsGoat's and Cow's Milk

Our partners at Haystack Mountain Goat Dairy are farmstead cheese making professionals using old world techniques and recipes. Your cheese is hand picked and shipped right from their cheese cave to your door. To ensure the quality of the cheese during delivery, all shipments will go out Monday through Wednesday with 1-2 day delivery.

FedEx Shipping Map for Otterbein Acres Farm | Revittle

*We provide free shipping to the following states with a minimum purchase of $100 of Haystack products (AZ, CO, KS, MT, NE, UT, WY). If shipping to a different state, you can choose either 2 day air or overnight - shipping charges will be automatically calculated upon checkout. Free shipping is supplier specific and cannot be combined with other suppliers. If you have any questions please email wholesale@revittle.com or call us directly 717.461.7447

Why Haystack Mountain cheese?

First off, it’s just delicious. Our cheesemaker Jackie Chang and her team have the patience, skill and sense of adventure to create cheeses known for their clean, fresh flavor profiles, free of “goaty” aftertaste. Even if you’ve shied away from goat cheese in the past, give Haystack’s a try. We can’t keep track of how many goat cheese converts we’ve won over with our products.

Second, all Haystack Mountain cheeses are handmade and free of additives or preservatives. We use the highest quality microbial (aka vegetarian) rennet, traditional cheesemaking techniques, and our cheeses are free of preservatives and artificial flavors. Nothing but pure delicious fat and protein.

Haystack Mountain Creamery's Cheesemaker Jackie Chang

Third, in keeping with tradition of the true Colorado locally sourced spirit, Haystack Mountain has partnered with our neighbor, Longmont Dairy, to create some of the most delicious cheeses made from cow’s milk and cow/goat milk blends. We’ve also partnered with CCI for our goat milk supply, and enjoy a mutually beneficial arrangement which enriches the lives of our community. We fully support our local friends, families and neighbors and we look forward to many more years of serving the cheeses we love to the people we love.